Most people think pins are just accessories. I think they're tiny storytelling devices. For Matt and Tommy fans, each pin is a capsule of a moment - a callback to a specific bit, a meme, or a shared experience. And in 2026, the collection has never been more intentional.
← Back to Blog
Collectible Matt and Tommy pins and keychains 2026
Discover the best Matt and Tommy pins and keychains of 2026 - from limited edition drops to display tips that protect your collection.
Why collectibles matter to Matt and Tommy fans
The duo's community has grown from a small Discord server to over 5 million subscribers across platforms. Along the way, inside jokes became currency. A pin of a llama isn't just a pin - it's the "Llama Drama" arc from their 2024 Minecraft series. That connection drives collectors.I've worked with creator merch for years, and what sets Matt and Tommy apart is how they treat each drop as a narrative. They don't just slap a logo on enamel. They commission original art from fan-favorite illustrators, use unique colors (like that iridescent glow on the "Ghost of Season 3" pin), and number every limited run.
Collecting becomes a way to physically own a piece of the story. It's the same impulse that drives people to buy vinyl records at concerts - except these pins are wearable, tradeable, and often appreciate in sentimental value faster than resale price.
Top pin designs from the 2026 collection
The 2026 lineup focuses on three themes: callbacks, collaborations, and chaos.Callback pins
These reimagine iconic moments from earlier years. The "Pie In The Face" pin (a round 1.5-inch enamel design with a gold border) references a 2022 punishment challenge. It's Matt's favorite because, as he said on stream, "Every time I see it, I remember the cleanup." Only 1,000 were made.Collaboration pins
New this year: crossover pins with fellow creators. Two standouts:- The "VS" series (Matt & Tommy facing off against another duo) - each with split enamel colors (red vs blue)
- The "Team Up" pin - a shared design that connects two pins when placed side by side (magnetic backing, nickel-plated)
Chaos pins
These are the chaotic-energy designs. The "Oops All Bananas" pin (a soft enamel 1.25-inch design with a banana pattern inside a squiggly border) sold out in 12 hours. Tommy reportedly said in a private Discord message, "It's the pinnacle of nonsense and I love it."Must-have keychain styles this year
Pins get the spotlight, but keychains are the workhorses of daily carry. This year's collection leans into function and personality.Bottle opener keychains
These double as bottle openers and feature acrylic charms of Matt and Tommy's faces (simplified vector style). The face is on one side; on the reverse, a small quote: "This is fine" (Matt) or "Worth it" (Tommy). Retail: $14.99 each. I own the Tommy version and can confirm it opens a bottle in one smooth motion - tested on two different caps.Glow-in-the-dark keychains
A new material this year: infused phosphorescent pigment. The "Night Stream" keychain (2 inches tall) shows a pixel-art moon with a tiny couch. Charged under a desk lamp for 30 seconds, it glows for about 3 hours. Perfect for finding keys in a dark bag.Mini character keychains
These are 1-inch acrylic standees with a split ring. Each keychain features a chibi version of Matt or Tommy in a different outfit (streamer mode, beach day, formal disaster). The formal disaster outfit - a tuxedo with mismatched socks - is already a fan favorite.How to display your growing collection
Once you own 10+ pins, keeping them in a drawer feels wrong. But not all display methods protect the enamel or keep the backing intact. Here's what I've learned from organizing my own 30+ collection.Pin boards vs. canvas frames
- Cork boards: Cheap but require care. Use felt-tipped push pins (the enamel kind can scratch pin backs). I recommend boards at least 1/2 inch thick to hold heavier pins.
- Canvas frames: Stretch fabric over a frame (easel style or wall mount). The fabric is gentle on pin posts and you can swap layouts without damaging the board.
- Shadow boxes: Best for limited editions. A 12x16 shadow box with a 1-inch depth holds about 15 pins comfortably. Add a strip of LED tape inside for a gallery effect.
Rotation is key
I rotate my wall display monthly. The "current favorites" go front and center; retired pins go into a binder with archival plastic sleeves (acid-free, PVC-free). This keeps them dust-free and preserves the enamel shine.What NOT to do
- Don't mount pins on denim jackets long-term unless you're wearing them regularly. The friction can wear down the pin clutch.
- Don't stack pins on top of each other. The posts can bend.
- Don't store loose in a drawer. The soft enamel can chip against each other.
Limited edition drops to watch for
Matt and Tommy release pins in batches, typically through their merch store. 2026 has three confirmed limited drops."The Anniversary Set" (August)
Celebrating 5 years of their channel. Six pins, each representing a milestone year, with a die-cut box designed to look like an old video tape case. Only 2,000 sets globally."Fan Art Compilation" (October)
Each month leading up to October, they'll highlight one fan-submitted design on social media. The winning designs will be turned into a 5-pin set. Entries close July 31."Mystery Mini Pin Series" (December)
A blind box format: 12 designs, each randomly packed in opaque bags. One in 50 has a gold-plated variant with Tommy's signature etched on the back. Retail $10 per bag. Full set resells for roughly 4x retail on secondary markets.Pro tip
Follow their Twitter and join the Discord. The store usually sends a notification 24 hours before a drop. But fast sellouts happen within minutes.FAQ
Are Matt and Tommy pins official merchandise?
These pins are created by the store as fan-inspired collectibles. They are not officially licensed by Matt and Tommy, but many designs reference moments from their content with their awareness.What materials are used in the pins?
Most are soft enamel with gold or silver nickel plating. The mini keychains use durable acrylic. The glow-in-the-dark keychains use a non-toxic phosphorescent pigment.How do I care for enamel pins?
Clean with a soft dry cloth. Avoid water and direct sunlight for long periods. Store in acid-free bags or a shadow box to prevent tarnish.Do you ship internationally?
Yes, we ship to select countries via print-on-demand. Standard shipping to the US takes 5-10 business days. International options are available at checkout.Can I trade pins with other collectors?
While we don't facilitate trades directly, many fans organize swaps in the community Discord server. Just ensure pins are in mint condition (no scratches or bent posts). - -Key Takeaways
- Collectible pins connect fans to specific moments in Matt and Tommy's content
- 2026 highlights callback designs, collaborations, and chaotic art
- Keychains now serve dual purposes: functional (bottle openers) and fun (glow-in-the-dark)
- Proper display methods extend pin life: shadow boxes and archival binders are best
- Limited drops require fast action - follow community channels for alerts
About the author: Mia Chen is a digital artist and merch designer specializing in gaming and creator merchandise. She has designed over 100 enamel pins for various creators and runs a weekly newsletter on collectible design trends.
Related Posts
undefined
Matt Tommy Desk Organizers: Best Dorm Storage for 2026
Find the best Matt Tommy desk organizers for your 2026 dorm room. From pencil cups to laptop stands,...
undefinedMatt Tommy Lunch Boxes 2026 Best Picks for Back to School
Discover the top Matt Tommy lunch boxes for back to school 2026, with expert tips on durability, cle...
undefinedBest Matt & Tommy Phone Cases and Tech Accessories 2026
Our guide to the best Matt & Tommy phone cases and tech accessories in 2026 covers five top case des...
Shop Matt & Tommy Merch
Official merchandise — premium quality, designed for the community.
